Our AI writing assistant, WriteUp, can assist you in easily writing any text. Click here to experience its capabilities.

Is math real? The answer has major practical and philosophical implications

View Original View Raw

Summary

This article explores the philosophical and practical implications of whether or not math is a universal reality. It traces the debate back to ancient Greek philosopher Plato, who proposed mathematics as a hidden, ideal reality, and examines how modern science has continued to build on this idea. It also looks at the potential consequences of math being real or not, such as whether we would be able to communicate with aliens. The article concludes by posing the question of whether math is real or not to the reader.

Q&As

What is the philosophical question behind the practical implications of mathematics?
The philosophical question behind the practical implications of mathematics is whether math is a universal reality or something that we invent.

What implications does the answer to this question have on our ability to communicate with aliens?
If Platonism is right, then all mathematical truth would have to be universal, and we could use math as a kind of interstellar Rosetta Stone to communicate with aliens. If mathematics is something invented and not discovered, then there would be no reason to think alien math has anything to do with our own, and we might never be able to communicate.

What was Plato's view of mathematics?
Plato proposed mathematics as a hidden, ideal reality that underpinned this one. He believed that the geometrical relationships for a triangle constituted the perfect and true triangle, and that all the triangles encountered in life were flawed, lesser examples of the ones math described.

What does Eugene Wigner mean by "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences"?
Eugene Wigner is saying that the ability of abstract mathematics to describe the world is miraculous and that we do not understand or deserve it.

What is the difference between Platonist and non-Platonist views of mathematics?
Platonist views believe that mathematics is inscribed into the fabric of reality, while non-Platonist views deny the idea that math is the most real thing there is and believe that math works because we invented it.

AI Comments

👍 This article provides an interesting insight into the complex relationship between mathematics and reality. The philosophical implications are thought-provoking and it's exciting to consider the possibility of using mathematics to communicate with alien species.

👎 This article is overly long and could have been more concise. Additionally, it fails to provide any concrete conclusions and offers no solutions.

AI Discussion

Me: It's about whether math is a real, universal reality or just something we invented. It has some really interesting implications, both practical and philosophical.

Friend: Interesting. What kind of implications?

Me: Well, if math is a real, universal reality, then it could be a way to communicate with aliens if we ever make contact with them. On the other hand, if math is just something we invented, then there would be no reason to think alien math has anything to do with our own, and we might never be able to communicate with them. It's a really fascinating question.

Action items

Research the philosophical implications of mathematics and its relationship to reality.
Explore the practical implications of mathematics in modern life.
Read Eugene Wigner’s essay “The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences” to gain a better understanding of the power of mathematics.

Technical terms

Platonism: A philosophical system developed by Plato, which holds that the physical world is an imperfect reflection of a higher, ideal reality.
Calculus: A branch of mathematics that deals with the study of change and motion.
Dynamical equations: Mathematical equations that describe the motion of objects in a system.
Hyper-donut: A geometric shape that resembles a multi-dimensional donut.
Spacetime: A mathematical model that combines space and time into a single continuum.
Quantum mechanics: A branch of physics that deals with the behavior of matter and energy at the atomic and subatomic level.
Eugene Wigner: A Hungarian-American physicist who wrote the essay “The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences.”
George Lakoff: A cognitive scientist who proposed the view that mathematics works because we invented it.