All Advertising Looks the Same These Days. Blame the Moodboard
Raw Text
áŠ( ° Ê Â°)ဠThe ultimate flex: a full set of EoD Mag on your bookshelf áŠ( ° Ê Â°)á€
S e a r c h
R e l a t e d A r t i c l e s
S o m e t h i n g D i f f e r e n t
S e a r c h
R e l a t e d A r t i c l e s
S o m e t h i n g D i f f e r e n t
Search
Menu
Social
Branding
Words by Elizabeth Goodspeed
Published on March 24th, 2022
Youâve seen it before: an isolated medicine cabinet, filled with a range of beautifully packaged products, photographed head-on in front of a flat backdrop. The lighting is bold and bright, as if the whole shelving unit is illuminated from behind by a fluorescent lightbox. The shelves themselves are likely made of glass, providing a certain je ne sais quoi thatâs integral to the elevated resultâa seamless blend of the mundane with the ethereal. This art direction style, dubbed the âshelfie,â began with a 1982 Clinique campaign by Irving Penn, and since then dozens of brands and publications have adopted the style, transforming it from a brilliant composition to a personal care trope.
There are many more oft-mimicked setups like the shelfie currently bouncing around the zeitgeist; one omnipresent shot includes objects placed on a mirror reflecting the sky , giving the illusion of a product floating in midair. Another example uses a dense pattern of water droplets to refract a single item into a series of psychedelic miniatures , while yet another places subjects in front of faux scenic backdrops reminiscent of a low-budget Sears photo studio. Each of these distinct setups is utilized broadly and across industries, with the same composition and concept seen on the Instagram feeds of a major beverage syndicate and an indie skincare brand alike.
While each photo trend is precise in its particulars, on closer examination, the photos across trends begin to resemble one another as well; objects start to float against landscape backdrops instead of clouds, and shelves become spotted with dew drops . Itâs as if thereâs a hidden network of identical references hiding behind every photoâeach shot finding inspiration in the aesthetic components of the last, like an elaborate game of telephone. Once you start to notice the recurring elements embedded in every ânewâ compositional approach, itâs like a sixth sense (or maybe more like a brain worm) that you canât shut off.
This kind of visual homogeneity is a common occurrence in the art direction world, where ubiquitous styles operate less like trends and more like memes; remixed and diluted until they become a single visual mass. In todayâs extremely-online world, the vast availability of reference imagery has, perhaps counterintuitively, led to narrower thinking and shallower visual ideation. Itâs a product of what I like to call the âmoodboard effect.â
Visual homogeneity is a common occurrence in the art direction world, where ubiquitous styles operate less like trends and more like memes.
Unlike graphic design, where client approval typically happens after work has been created, in art direction the order is flipped, with client sign-off required before any imagery has been made. This gap between sign-off and execution is where the moodboard comes in: art directors are expected to provide a variety of boards that break down every aspect of a shoot (from lighting to propping) as well as a shot list that will be strictly followed by a photographer. This pressure to provide final results in advance of production encourages art directors to only propose ideas that they can find existing photographic examples of, and to ultimately recreate these ideas on setâno matter that for much of the past, simple sketches or written descriptions of shots were more than adequate to demonstrate an intended visual result.
Of course, the rise and fall of trends themselves in visual culture is nothing new. If youâre a regular AIGA Eye on Design reader, the Spotted column is a testament to the vast number of design motifs that pass through the commercial world on a regular basis. But whatâs unique about art direction trends seems to be the consistency with which particular combinations of formal tropes recur, combined with a detachment from the meaning behind those forms. Whereas a design feature like a fruit sticker has both a functional purpose (an easy way to chunk out content) and an underlying expressive rationale (serving as a âseal of approvalâ), brandsâ usages of many art direction motifs, like mirrored reflections or sunset backdrops , increasingly seem unrelated to the brandsâ overall aesthetic, product line, or strategic mission.
Instead, these visual cues operate on a surface level, rendering form without function. In a recent interview with The Brand Identity , Jesse Reed, co-founder of NY design studio Order , reiterated this idea and communicated his studioâs distaste for moodboarding, stating: âmoodboards result in visual derivatives⊠leading with aesthetic influences as opposed to meaningful connections further propels the cycle of sameness.â
The way in which images are selected and placed within the context of the moodboard is the driving force behind the aesthetic monotony seen in brand photography. Art directors, tasked with sourcing imagery quickly and precisely, are increasingly turning to collective inspiration websites like Pinterest or Are.na to locate reference images. On these sites, by design, creatives are encouraged to bucket out imagery into thematically consistent folders to be shared and mined by other visitors. But by stripping imagery from its in-situ context, it becomes difficult to grasp the conceptual rationale behind their formal appearance.
Reference images are considered only by era , by subject , or by setting , rather than as a unified amalgamation of ideas and aesthetics. As a result, when designers are researching references for, say, a skincare shoot for a product that comes in glass bottles, they are more likely than ever to limit their research to aggregate boards that only trade in still life or glass bottles or beauty. When these borrowed images are further compiled into the form of art direction moodboards, theyâre so ideologically flattened that itâs near impossible to use them as a brainstorming tool for new ideasâthey become a rigid road map instead. While curation is undoubtedly an artform in its own right, to borrow critic Fran Leibowitz âs words: a sense of discovery is not equal to invention.
Looking at the arc of the shelfie trend, you can see this semiotic degeneration in real time. Hilma , a clean herbal medicine company and an early contemporary adopter of the shelfie composition, clearly uses the shelfie format with strategic storytelling in mind. In the brandâs original use of the photo on their website, designed by Little Troop , the viewer sees shelves of artificial-looking medicine transform into all natural remediesâpaired with a copy line that explicitly mentions âcleaning upâ your medicine cabinet.
The shelfie shot sits comfortably within an ecosystem of similar art direction for the brand at large; both conceptually, as in the case of other before-and-after moments, and aesthetically, through the use of similar lightbox style photography in other product photos. Conversely, by the time the trend trickles down to locations like Mr Porter or Not Pot, itâs significantly more disconnected from a real medicine cabinet: how many people actually keep seven perfumes behind their bathroom mirror, or use their powder room shelving for a Rubikâs cubes? While art direction is arguably always more aspirational than practical, these later use cases feel like a stretch.
What happens when you let what youâve seen filter through the lens of your own memory, rather than working directly from a reference on a page?
So where do we go from here? Avoiding repetition may be as simple as looking outside of the world of contemporary graphic design and art direction for inspiration, and certainly outside the client industry youâre working in, whether that be by referencing the past, or other creative fields like architecture or fine art. If youâre excited by the idea of reflection as seen in the cloud-mirror photos, why not see how Ekkehard Altenburger or Yayoi Kusama have played with mirrors in their work?
The internet can be an asset to research, but intentionality in sourcing shows wisdom and intellect; a solid concept with fewer examples is always better than an oft-trodden one with a plethora of precedents. Even more simply: trust your intuition. Chances are youâve absorbed enough of the current visual climate by osmosis alone; what happens when you let what youâve seen filter through the lens of your own memory, rather than working directly from a reference on a page? Ultimately, reference imagery should be used as a tool, not a productâleading to visual iteration, not limiting it.
Share: Twitter Facebook Pinterest Email
Branding
Related Articles
Design + Education
Creative Director and Teacher Forest Young on Designing a More Inclusive Future
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Op-ed
Design Criticism Is EverywhereâWhy Are We Still Looking For It?
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Magazines
Open Manifesto âthe Quiet but Persistent Australian Design JournalâWas Ahead of Its Time
You probably donât need me to tell you that the publishing world is a tough business. While the internet ââŠ
AIGA Medalists
Emily Oberman Shaped the Look of Pop Culture as We Know It
It was only 50 cents. But it was 50 cents that perhaps changed the look of pop culture as weâŠ
Magazines
You Think You Know People But You Have No Idea
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Books
Hereâs Why John Updike Designed His Own Book Covers
Last summer, while browsing the fiction aisles at Powellâs Books in Portland, a fat black spine caught my attention. AtâŠ
AIGA Medalists
Andrew Satake Blauvelt Elevated Graphic Design Far Beyond Notions of âProblem Solvingâ
âGraphic design must be seen as a discipline capable of generating meaning on its own terms without undue reliance onâŠ
Typography
Hereâs a Thought: What if Letterforms Had More Serifs?
Westenwind, a new font designed by Olga Umpeleva at the KABK TypeMedia master program in the Netherlands, grew from aâŠ
Design + Sexuality
The UX of Porn Tube Sites Are Designed for the Ultimate Money Shot
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Fashion
Design Trends Come and Go. But Thereâs A Reason Why Graphic Knitwear Transcends
From the family-knit cardigans of infancy, to the House of Sunny âfits of todayâs Tik Tokers duâjour, societyâs enduring loveâŠ
Design History 101
Knowing Your Design History is Crucial to Aesthetic Innovation
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Typography
Meet Ange Degheest, Pioneering 20th-Century Female Type Designer
âAnge Degheestâs story is remarkable and a perfect illustration of the technical odyssey that took place throughout the twentieth century.ââŠ
Newsletter
AIGA Eye on Design Conference
Join AIGA
About
@AIGAeyeondesign
© Copyright 2021 · AIGA
About
Eye on Design Magazine
S e a r c h
S o m e t h i n g D i f f e r e n t
Close
Or Filter By Your Interest
Design
Books
Magazines
Illustration
Digital
Branding
Typography
Graphic design
Packaging design
Design +
Design + Art
Design + Sexuality
Design + Music
Design + Money
Design + Mental Health
Design + Diversity
Design + Politics
Design + Education
Design Series
Where Designers Work
First Thing I Ever Designed
Design Diary
Type Tuesday
Poster Picks
Love Letters
Happy Hour
Design History 101
Design Quotes
Countries
Australia
Canada
Central Europe
Eastern Europe
Japan
Mexico
Scandinavia
Southeast Asia
South America
U.S.
UK
Western Europe
Loading âŠ
Sorry, no results were found.
Results
Branding
Youâve seen it before: an isolated medicine cabinet, filled with a range of beautifully packaged products, photographed head-on in frontâŠ
Design
Graphic design
Branding
Books
Magazines
Illustration
Digital
Typography
Design +
Design + Mental Health
Design + Money
Design + Art
Design + Diversity
Design + Education
Design + Sexuality
Design + Music
Design + Politics
Design + Gender
Design Series
Op-ed
Where Designers Work
Weekend With
Profiles
Happy Hour
First Thing I Ever Designed
Type Tuesday
Rejected Designs
Poster Picks
Satire
Design History 101
Community
Eye on Design Events
Eye on Design Magazine
Eye on Design City Guides
Magazine
Newsletter
Video
About
Close
Design + Education
Creative Director and Teacher Forest Young on Designing a More Inclusive Future
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Op-ed
Design Criticism Is EverywhereâWhy Are We Still Looking For It?
This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. ItâŠ
Magazines
Open Manifesto âthe Quiet but Persistent Australian Design JournalâWas Ahead of Its Time
You probably donât need me to tell you that the publishing world is a tough business. While the internet ââŠ
AIGA Medalists
Emily Oberman Shaped the Look of Pop Culture as We Know It
It was only 50 cents. But it was 50 cents that perhaps changed the look of pop culture as weâŠ
Single Line Text
áŠ( ° Ê Â°)ဠThe ultimate flex: a full set of EoD Mag on your bookshelf áŠ( ° Ê Â°)á€. S e a r c h. R e l a t e d A r t i c l e s. S o m e t h i n g D i f f e r e n t. Twitter. Facebook. Pinterest. Email. S e a r c h. R e l a t e d A r t i c l e s. S o m e t h i n g D i f f e r e n t. Search. Menu. Social. Branding. Words by Elizabeth Goodspeed. Published on March 24th, 2022. Youâve seen it before: an isolated medicine cabinet, filled with a range of beautifully packaged products, photographed head-on in front of a flat backdrop. The lighting is bold and bright, as if the whole shelving unit is illuminated from behind by a fluorescent lightbox. The shelves themselves are likely made of glass, providing a certain je ne sais quoi thatâs integral to the elevated resultâa seamless blend of the mundane with the ethereal. This art direction style, dubbed the âshelfie,â began with a 1982 Clinique campaign by Irving Penn, and since then dozens of brands and publications have adopted the style, transforming it from a brilliant composition to a personal care trope. There are many more oft-mimicked setups like the shelfie currently bouncing around the zeitgeist; one omnipresent shot includes objects placed on a mirror reflecting the sky , giving the illusion of a product floating in midair. Another example uses a dense pattern of water droplets to refract a single item into a series of psychedelic miniatures , while yet another places subjects in front of faux scenic backdrops reminiscent of a low-budget Sears photo studio. Each of these distinct setups is utilized broadly and across industries, with the same composition and concept seen on the Instagram feeds of a major beverage syndicate and an indie skincare brand alike. While each photo trend is precise in its particulars, on closer examination, the photos across trends begin to resemble one another as well; objects start to float against landscape backdrops instead of clouds, and shelves become spotted with dew drops . Itâs as if thereâs a hidden network of identical references hiding behind every photoâeach shot finding inspiration in the aesthetic components of the last, like an elaborate game of telephone. Once you start to notice the recurring elements embedded in every ânewâ compositional approach, itâs like a sixth sense (or maybe more like a brain worm) that you canât shut off. This kind of visual homogeneity is a common occurrence in the art direction world, where ubiquitous styles operate less like trends and more like memes; remixed and diluted until they become a single visual mass. In todayâs extremely-online world, the vast availability of reference imagery has, perhaps counterintuitively, led to narrower thinking and shallower visual ideation. Itâs a product of what I like to call the âmoodboard effect.â Visual homogeneity is a common occurrence in the art direction world, where ubiquitous styles operate less like trends and more like memes. Unlike graphic design, where client approval typically happens after work has been created, in art direction the order is flipped, with client sign-off required before any imagery has been made. This gap between sign-off and execution is where the moodboard comes in: art directors are expected to provide a variety of boards that break down every aspect of a shoot (from lighting to propping) as well as a shot list that will be strictly followed by a photographer. This pressure to provide final results in advance of production encourages art directors to only propose ideas that they can find existing photographic examples of, and to ultimately recreate these ideas on setâno matter that for much of the past, simple sketches or written descriptions of shots were more than adequate to demonstrate an intended visual result. Of course, the rise and fall of trends themselves in visual culture is nothing new. If youâre a regular AIGA Eye on Design reader, the Spotted column is a testament to the vast number of design motifs that pass through the commercial world on a regular basis. But whatâs unique about art direction trends seems to be the consistency with which particular combinations of formal tropes recur, combined with a detachment from the meaning behind those forms. Whereas a design feature like a fruit sticker has both a functional purpose (an easy way to chunk out content) and an underlying expressive rationale (serving as a âseal of approvalâ), brandsâ usages of many art direction motifs, like mirrored reflections or sunset backdrops , increasingly seem unrelated to the brandsâ overall aesthetic, product line, or strategic mission. Instead, these visual cues operate on a surface level, rendering form without function. In a recent interview with The Brand Identity , Jesse Reed, co-founder of NY design studio Order , reiterated this idea and communicated his studioâs distaste for moodboarding, stating: âmoodboards result in visual derivatives⊠leading with aesthetic influences as opposed to meaningful connections further propels the cycle of sameness.â The way in which images are selected and placed within the context of the moodboard is the driving force behind the aesthetic monotony seen in brand photography. Art directors, tasked with sourcing imagery quickly and precisely, are increasingly turning to collective inspiration websites like Pinterest or Are.na to locate reference images. On these sites, by design, creatives are encouraged to bucket out imagery into thematically consistent folders to be shared and mined by other visitors. But by stripping imagery from its in-situ context, it becomes difficult to grasp the conceptual rationale behind their formal appearance. Reference images are considered only by era , by subject , or by setting , rather than as a unified amalgamation of ideas and aesthetics. As a result, when designers are researching references for, say, a skincare shoot for a product that comes in glass bottles, they are more likely than ever to limit their research to aggregate boards that only trade in still life or glass bottles or beauty. When these borrowed images are further compiled into the form of art direction moodboards, theyâre so ideologically flattened that itâs near impossible to use them as a brainstorming tool for new ideasâthey become a rigid road map instead. While curation is undoubtedly an artform in its own right, to borrow critic Fran Leibowitz âs words: a sense of discovery is not equal to invention. Looking at the arc of the shelfie trend, you can see this semiotic degeneration in real time. Hilma , a clean herbal medicine company and an early contemporary adopter of the shelfie composition, clearly uses the shelfie format with strategic storytelling in mind. In the brandâs original use of the photo on their website, designed by Little Troop , the viewer sees shelves of artificial-looking medicine transform into all natural remediesâpaired with a copy line that explicitly mentions âcleaning upâ your medicine cabinet. The shelfie shot sits comfortably within an ecosystem of similar art direction for the brand at large; both conceptually, as in the case of other before-and-after moments, and aesthetically, through the use of similar lightbox style photography in other product photos. Conversely, by the time the trend trickles down to locations like Mr Porter or Not Pot, itâs significantly more disconnected from a real medicine cabinet: how many people actually keep seven perfumes behind their bathroom mirror, or use their powder room shelving for a Rubikâs cubes? While art direction is arguably always more aspirational than practical, these later use cases feel like a stretch. What happens when you let what youâve seen filter through the lens of your own memory, rather than working directly from a reference on a page? So where do we go from here? Avoiding repetition may be as simple as looking outside of the world of contemporary graphic design and art direction for inspiration, and certainly outside the client industry youâre working in, whether that be by referencing the past, or other creative fields like architecture or fine art. If youâre excited by the idea of reflection as seen in the cloud-mirror photos, why not see how Ekkehard Altenburger or Yayoi Kusama have played with mirrors in their work? The internet can be an asset to research, but intentionality in sourcing shows wisdom and intellect; a solid concept with fewer examples is always better than an oft-trodden one with a plethora of precedents. Even more simply: trust your intuition. Chances are youâve absorbed enough of the current visual climate by osmosis alone; what happens when you let what youâve seen filter through the lens of your own memory, rather than working directly from a reference on a page? Ultimately, reference imagery should be used as a tool, not a productâleading to visual iteration, not limiting it. Share: Twitter Facebook Pinterest Email. Branding. Related Articles. Design + Education. Creative Director and Teacher Forest Young on Designing a More Inclusive Future. This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Op-ed. Design Criticism Is EverywhereâWhy Are We Still Looking For It? This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Magazines. Open Manifesto âthe Quiet but Persistent Australian Design JournalâWas Ahead of Its Time. You probably donât need me to tell you that the publishing world is a tough business. While the internet â⊠AIGA Medalists. Emily Oberman Shaped the Look of Pop Culture as We Know It. It was only 50 cents. But it was 50 cents that perhaps changed the look of pop culture as we⊠Magazines. You Think You Know People But You Have No Idea. This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Books. Hereâs Why John Updike Designed His Own Book Covers. Last summer, while browsing the fiction aisles at Powellâs Books in Portland, a fat black spine caught my attention. At⊠AIGA Medalists. Andrew Satake Blauvelt Elevated Graphic Design Far Beyond Notions of âProblem Solvingâ âGraphic design must be seen as a discipline capable of generating meaning on its own terms without undue reliance on⊠Typography. Hereâs a Thought: What if Letterforms Had More Serifs? Westenwind, a new font designed by Olga Umpeleva at the KABK TypeMedia master program in the Netherlands, grew from a⊠Design + Sexuality. The UX of Porn Tube Sites Are Designed for the Ultimate Money Shot. This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Fashion. Design Trends Come and Go. But Thereâs A Reason Why Graphic Knitwear Transcends. From the family-knit cardigans of infancy, to the House of Sunny âfits of todayâs Tik Tokers duâjour, societyâs enduring love⊠Design History 101. Knowing Your Design History is Crucial to Aesthetic Innovation. This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Typography. Meet Ange Degheest, Pioneering 20th-Century Female Type Designer. âAnge Degheestâs story is remarkable and a perfect illustration of the technical odyssey that took place throughout the twentieth century.â⊠Newsletter. AIGA Eye on Design Conference. Join AIGA. About. @AIGAeyeondesign. © Copyright 2021 · AIGA. About. Eye on Design Magazine. Twitter. Facebook. Pinterest. Email. S e a r c h. S o m e t h i n g D i f f e r e n t. Close. Or Filter By Your Interest. Design. Books. Magazines. Illustration. Digital. Branding. Typography. Graphic design. Packaging design. Design +. Design + Art. Design + Sexuality. Design + Music. Design + Money. Design + Mental Health. Design + Diversity. Design + Politics. Design + Education. Design Series. Where Designers Work. First Thing I Ever Designed. Design Diary. Type Tuesday. Poster Picks. Love Letters. Happy Hour. Design History 101. Design Quotes. Countries. Australia. Canada. Central Europe. Eastern Europe. Japan. Mexico. Scandinavia. Southeast Asia. South America. U.S. UK. Western Europe. Loading ⊠Sorry, no results were found. Results. Branding. Youâve seen it before: an isolated medicine cabinet, filled with a range of beautifully packaged products, photographed head-on in front⊠Design. Graphic design. Branding. Books. Magazines. Illustration. Digital. Typography. Design +. Design + Mental Health. Design + Money. Design + Art. Design + Diversity. Design + Education. Design + Sexuality. Design + Music. Design + Politics. Design + Gender. Design Series. Op-ed. Where Designers Work. Weekend With. Profiles. Happy Hour. First Thing I Ever Designed. Type Tuesday. Rejected Designs. Poster Picks. Satire. Design History 101. Community. Eye on Design Events. Eye on Design Magazine. Eye on Design City Guides. Magazine. Newsletter. Video. About. Close. Design + Education. Creative Director and Teacher Forest Young on Designing a More Inclusive Future. This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Op-ed. Design Criticism Is EverywhereâWhy Are We Still Looking For It? This story is part of our Weekend Reads series, where we highlight a story we love from the archives. It⊠Magazines. Open Manifesto âthe Quiet but Persistent Australian Design JournalâWas Ahead of Its Time. You probably donât need me to tell you that the publishing world is a tough business. While the internet â⊠AIGA Medalists. Emily Oberman Shaped the Look of Pop Culture as We Know It. It was only 50 cents. But it was 50 cents that perhaps changed the look of pop culture as weâŠ