Judge finds forensic scientist Henry Lee liable for fabricating evidence in murder case

Raw Text

Connecticut

By Pat Eaton-Robb • Published July 21, 2023 • Updated on July 21, 2023 at 8:06 pm

Famed forensic scientist Henry Lee was found liable for fabricating evidence in a murder case that sent two Connecticut men to prison for decades for a crime they did not commit, a federal judge ruled Friday.

Ralph “Ricky” Birch and Shawn Henning were convicted in the Dec. 1, 1985, slaying of Everett Carr, based in part on testimony about what Lee said were bloodstains on a towel found in the 65-year-old's home in New Milford, 55 miles southwest of Hartford.

A judge vacated the felony murder convictions in 2020, and the men filed a federal wrongful conviction lawsuit naming Lee, eight police investigators and the town of New Milford.

The ruling Friday sends the case against the police and the town to trial. In granting a motion for summary judgement against Lee, the only outstanding issue for a jury in his case will be the amount of damages.

Get Connecticut local news, weather forecasts and entertainment stories to your inbox. Sign up for NBC Connecticut newsletters.

Lee, the former head of the state’s forensic laboratory and now a professor emeritus at the University of New Haven’s  Henry C. Lee College of Criminal Justice and Forensic Sciences , did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.

Lee, 84, rocketed to fame after his testimony in the 1995 O.J. Simpson murder trial, in which he questioned the handling of blood evidence. He also served as a consultant in other high-profile investigations, including the 1996 slaying of 6-year-old JonBenet Ramsey in Colorado; the 2004 murder trial of Scott Peterson, who was accused of killing his pregnant wife Laci; and the 2007 murder trial of record producer Phil Spector.

When Birch and Henning were put on trial in 1989, jurors heard about an extremely bloody crime scene. Carr had been stabbed 27 times, had his throat cut and suffered seven blows to the head.

Local

Connecticut

2 hours ago

False trooper ticket story author is 1 of 3 CT open government award winners

vernon

2 hours ago

Vernon officials investigate wave of dog abandonments

No forensic evidence existed linking Birch and Henning to the crime. No blood was found on their clothes or in their car. The crime scene included hairs and more than 40 fingerprints, but none matched the two men.

Prosecutors presented evidence from Lee — not yet famous — that it was possible for the assailants to avoid getting much blood on them.

Lee also testified that a towel, which later was suggested could have been touched by the killers while cleaning up, was found in a bathroom near the crime the scene with stains that he tested and were consistent with blood.

Tests done after the trial, when the men were appealing their convictions, showed the substance was not blood.

In his ruling Friday,  which was first reported by The Hart f ord Courant,  U.S. District Judge Victor Bolden ruled that Lee presented no evidence to back up his testimony.

“Other than stating that he performed the test, however, the record contains no evidence that any such test was performed,” the judge wrote. “In fact, as plaintiffs noted, Dr. Lee’s own experts concluded that there is no ‘written documentation or photographic’ evidence that Dr. Lee performed the TMB blood test. And there is evidence in this record that the tests actually conducted did not indicate the presence of blood.”

The judge also ruled that Lee failed to properly use an immunity defense that could have shielded him from damages and was no longer eligible to use that argument.

Elizabeth Benton, a spokesperson for Connecticut Attorney General William Tong, whose office defended Lee and the police detectives in the case, said it was reviewing the decision and evaluating the next steps.

Birch served more than 30 years of a 55-year sentence for felony murder before being released in 2019 after a judge ordered a new trial. Henning, who was 17 when the crime occurred, was granted probation in 2018.

After their convictions were vacated in 2020, Lee defended his conduct in the investigation.

“In my 57-year career, I have investigated over 8,000 cases and never, ever was accused of any wrongdoing or for testifying intentionally wrong,” Lee told reporters. “This is the first case that I have to defend myself.”

Lee's work in several other cases has come under scrutiny, including in the murder case against Spector, in which he was accused of taking evidence from the crime scene.

Associated Press writer Susan Haigh contributed to this report.

This article tagged under:

Connecticut

murder

Trending Stories

Sponsored Introducing the Ridge Recovery Center Promoted By Hartford HealthCare

vernon Impaired driver going 119 mph on I-84 had meth with ‘Breaking Bad' image: police

Sacred Heart University Two of five Sacred Heart students released from hospital after Friday's crash

Watertown Teen accidentally shot self in head while playing with unsecured gun in Watertown home: PD

stonington Man sentenced to 70 years in prison for killing Stonington woman in front of her kid

Weather Forecast

Single Line Text

Connecticut. By Pat Eaton-Robb • Published July 21, 2023 • Updated on July 21, 2023 at 8:06 pm. Famed forensic scientist Henry Lee was found liable for fabricating evidence in a murder case that sent two Connecticut men to prison for decades for a crime they did not commit, a federal judge ruled Friday. Ralph “Ricky” Birch and Shawn Henning were convicted in the Dec. 1, 1985, slaying of Everett Carr, based in part on testimony about what Lee said were bloodstains on a towel found in the 65-year-old's home in New Milford, 55 miles southwest of Hartford. A judge vacated the felony murder convictions in 2020, and the men filed a federal wrongful conviction lawsuit naming Lee, eight police investigators and the town of New Milford. The ruling Friday sends the case against the police and the town to trial. In granting a motion for summary judgement against Lee, the only outstanding issue for a jury in his case will be the amount of damages. Get Connecticut local news, weather forecasts and entertainment stories to your inbox. Sign up for NBC Connecticut newsletters. Lee, the former head of the state’s forensic laboratory and now a professor emeritus at the University of New Haven’s  Henry C. Lee College of Criminal Justice and Forensic Sciences , did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Lee, 84, rocketed to fame after his testimony in the 1995 O.J. Simpson murder trial, in which he questioned the handling of blood evidence. He also served as a consultant in other high-profile investigations, including the 1996 slaying of 6-year-old JonBenet Ramsey in Colorado; the 2004 murder trial of Scott Peterson, who was accused of killing his pregnant wife Laci; and the 2007 murder trial of record producer Phil Spector. When Birch and Henning were put on trial in 1989, jurors heard about an extremely bloody crime scene. Carr had been stabbed 27 times, had his throat cut and suffered seven blows to the head. Local. Connecticut. 2 hours ago. False trooper ticket story author is 1 of 3 CT open government award winners. vernon. 2 hours ago. Vernon officials investigate wave of dog abandonments. No forensic evidence existed linking Birch and Henning to the crime. No blood was found on their clothes or in their car. The crime scene included hairs and more than 40 fingerprints, but none matched the two men. Prosecutors presented evidence from Lee — not yet famous — that it was possible for the assailants to avoid getting much blood on them. Lee also testified that a towel, which later was suggested could have been touched by the killers while cleaning up, was found in a bathroom near the crime the scene with stains that he tested and were consistent with blood. Tests done after the trial, when the men were appealing their convictions, showed the substance was not blood. In his ruling Friday,  which was first reported by The Hart f ord Courant,  U.S. District Judge Victor Bolden ruled that Lee presented no evidence to back up his testimony. “Other than stating that he performed the test, however, the record contains no evidence that any such test was performed,” the judge wrote. “In fact, as plaintiffs noted, Dr. Lee’s own experts concluded that there is no ‘written documentation or photographic’ evidence that Dr. Lee performed the TMB blood test. And there is evidence in this record that the tests actually conducted did not indicate the presence of blood.” The judge also ruled that Lee failed to properly use an immunity defense that could have shielded him from damages and was no longer eligible to use that argument. Elizabeth Benton, a spokesperson for Connecticut Attorney General William Tong, whose office defended Lee and the police detectives in the case, said it was reviewing the decision and evaluating the next steps. Birch served more than 30 years of a 55-year sentence for felony murder before being released in 2019 after a judge ordered a new trial. Henning, who was 17 when the crime occurred, was granted probation in 2018. After their convictions were vacated in 2020, Lee defended his conduct in the investigation. “In my 57-year career, I have investigated over 8,000 cases and never, ever was accused of any wrongdoing or for testifying intentionally wrong,” Lee told reporters. “This is the first case that I have to defend myself.” Lee's work in several other cases has come under scrutiny, including in the murder case against Spector, in which he was accused of taking evidence from the crime scene. Associated Press writer Susan Haigh contributed to this report. This article tagged under: Connecticut. murder. Trending Stories. Sponsored Introducing the Ridge Recovery Center Promoted By Hartford HealthCare. vernon Impaired driver going 119 mph on I-84 had meth with ‘Breaking Bad' image: police. Sacred Heart University Two of five Sacred Heart students released from hospital after Friday's crash. Watertown Teen accidentally shot self in head while playing with unsecured gun in Watertown home: PD. stonington Man sentenced to 70 years in prison for killing Stonington woman in front of her kid. Weather Forecast.